SeedTree
All Fruit
Sapling: working in one or two places

Holistic planned grazing

Herders move livestock through many small paddocks on a written plan, giving each patch long rests so grass, soil and water recover.

Start small

Pick one paddock and split it into 4 to 8 strips with temporary electric fence for one season. Cost: roughly a solar energiser, reels and posts (a few hundred dollars). People: one manager plus a helper, 15 to 30 minutes a day. Before starting, photograph fixed points and do a simple infiltration test (a tin can and a jug of water) to compare after 1 to 3 years. Keep the stocking rate conservative.

The problem

Continuous, unplanned grazing strips grassland, compacts soil and loses soil carbon, worsening drought and climate change. Planned grazing aims to rebuild ground cover, water infiltration and soil carbon while keeping livestock income.

Where it fits

Has done best on humid and sub-humid grasslands with reliable rain (for example the south-east USA), on ranches where one committed manager watches the land closely and adjusts often. Needs fencing or herding labour, water points in each paddock, a stocking rate the land can carry, and years of patience. Results are weaker and less certain in dry rangelands.

The principle underneath

Grass and soil recover when grazing is short, intense and followed by a long rest timed to plant regrowth, and when a manager keeps adjusting animal numbers and moves to what the land is showing. Management attention and the right stocking rate seem to matter more than the paddock layout itself.

A pattern in nature

Large wild herds that bunch tightly against predators, graze and trample an area hard, then move on and do not return until it has regrown.

Who to call

Savory Institute and its regional hubs (e.g. Africa Centre for Holistic Management, Zimbabwe); Richard Teague, Texas A&M AgriLife Research; Jason Rowntree, Michigan State University; Peter Byck, Arizona State University (AMP grazing research); White Oak Pastures, Bluffton, Georgia; Heidi-Jayne Hawkins, University of Cape Town (for a critical view).

Watch out for

Overstocking because the plan seems to allow more animals. Moving herds by the calendar instead of by plant recovery. Claiming carbon gains without baseline soil samples to depth. Underestimating daily labour and water infrastructure. Treating it as a branded recipe rather than adaptive management. Using it in very dry areas where rest alone does not bring grass back. Carbon gains can level off and be lost if management lapses.

Where it comes from

Developed by Allan Savory in Zimbabwe from the 1960s, building on André Voisin's rational grazing (France, 1950s) and on observing wild herds. The Savory Institute trains and accredits practitioners. Many pastoralist peoples have long practised herded, mobile grazing with rest periods; where a project draws on a specific community's herding knowledge, ask and credit the custodians. This card uses only published research and public material.

Where it's worked

  • Paired ranches in Alabama, Mississippi, Kentucky and Tennessee, USA · Published 2022

    Adaptive multi-paddock ranches had over 13% more soil organic carbon to 1 m, higher average water infiltration, over 300% more standing plant biomass and higher stocking than neighbouring continuously grazed ranches; bare ground results were mixed and worse at the Tennessee pair.

    Peer reviewedSource

  • White Oak Pastures, Bluffton, Georgia, USA · 20-year chronosequence, published 2020

    Multi-species rotational grazing built soil carbon at about 2.29 t C/ha/yr, cutting net emissions by 80% and giving a footprint 66% below conventional beef, but needed about 2.5 times more land per unit of food.

    Peer reviewedSource

  • Global rangelands (synthesis of 47 grazing experiments) · Published 2008

    Rotational grazing was not superior to continuous grazing for plant or animal production; differences came down to management quality and stocking rate.

    Peer reviewedSource

  • Global (meta-analysis of 21 studies, 1972 to 2016) · Published 2017

    No significant difference between Holistic Planned Grazing and continuous grazing in basal cover, biomass or animal gain; positive results came mainly from higher-rainfall sites. The Savory Institute published a rebuttal.

    Peer reviewedSource

Where it failed

A 2008 review of 47 grazing experiments (Briske et al.) found rotational grazing no better than continuous grazing for plant or animal production across many rangelands. A 2017 meta-analysis of 21 studies (Hawkins) found no significant difference between Holistic Planned Grazing and continuous grazing in plant cover, biomass or animal weight gain; positive results clustered in wetter areas. The Savory Institute disputes both. Even the strongest farm study (White Oak Pastures, Georgia) found the system needed about 2.5 times more land for the same food as conventional beef, and bare ground increased under adaptive grazing at one Tennessee ranch pair in a 2022 study.